I have sat back for too long and watched politics become so ridiculous,
polarizing and categorically wrong. The two main problems with
people in today's political discourse is the us versus them mentality and
the failure to argue with real facts. Social media has allowed everyone
to become an "expert" in every situation and I am tired of
misinformation.
One of my MBA professors told us on the first day of this semester
"contrary to what you may believe, you are not entitled to your opinion;
you are only entitled to what you can back-up with evidence." He
admitted the line wasn't his and passed out an excellent article from a
philosophy professor (
here)
explaining the point. I was incredulous. How could he tell us that
we were not allowed to have our own opinion?! Throughout the semester,
however, I have realized the wisdom in this statement and believe it to be
wholeheartedly true. He has provided example after example of commonly
held beliefs in society that are flat out wrong or are, at a minimum, highly
misguided. Here is one example... Are there too many frivolous
lawsuits out there? You probably said, YES and my proof is McDonalds and
spilled Coffee. I would be willing to bet you don't know the whole story
because the story has been manipulated and changed so many times... (
the facts).
In another class, with the same professor, he said something else that was
truly profound in my opinion. "Nowadays, people don't search for
information, they search for validation." Think about it, the last
time that you saw something online that was against your own beliefs, did you
research the point to discredit it, prove it, or find real facts? I will
admit that I default to the first and now I force myself to approach anything I
don't like, or even things I completely agree, with a healthy skepticism and an
open mind. How is it possible for a modern society to be so
"right" all the time? It is impossible that most of my FB
friends are experts in Foreign Policy, Race Relations, Economic Inequality AND
Domestic Policies at the same time!
Then there comes the magical False Dichotomy or False Dilemma (
discussion here) where
individuals incorrectly state there are only two possible outcomes to the
situation. Think about how pervasive this is in modern politics.
"You are either with us or against us."
"You are either for or against killing babies."
"You are pro-business or pro-working class."
"If you don't support the war you are against our troops."
How can we have so many situations where there is no gray area? Yes,
there are definitely situations where the choice is either one outcome or the
other, but most situations are more nuanced. By creating this type of
rhetoric and polarization, the media, politicians and the general public
unfortunately think they have to choose sides in arguments. Why can't we
admit that most problems have multiple viewpoints, extenuating circumstance or
outcomes? My answer... We are too lazy, stupid and don't care enough
to actually research the whole situation. We also are so used to instant
gratification today that waiting is seen as a weakness. I would love to
see more politicians say "I don't have all the facts at this point and
would like to withhold comment until I have done more research." But
most people and journalists would hit that person with "how doesn't he/she
know this? How are they in Congress and don't know (blank)?"
Well the next time you say that, please remember you don't know everything, I
don't know everything, and the public definitely doesn't know everything.
We should be ever mindful of the profound thought attributed to Socrates and
Plato "I am the wisest man alive, for I know one thing, and that is
that I know nothing."
You will notice that at no point have I said anything about any one
particular view point. I don't care the situation, if you are going
to espouse an opinion then it better be backed by facts, research and a real
dialogue and not just what you "believe." It is time to move
the discussion forward and I hope to do my little part in that endeavor.
In the meantime, I will be keeping clear of social
media "discussions." You all don't want a legitimate
dialogue, you just want to be right and shout louder than the rest.
In the end, we all have one vote and most
people don’t even use it, so please refrain from speaking unless you are able
to back it up and you are willing to do something about it.